Before You Blame the Donors, Try Using Your Own Website!
Nonprofit website strategies for fundraising starts with a surprisingly tough question: Can visitors do what they came to do? Your mission may be inspiring. Your website’s navigation should not require a treasure map!
Kiersten Hill of Firespring shows us how audience needs, some smart techchoices, and truly coordinated campaigns can turn your website into a harder-working member of the promo team.
Kiersten discusses her updated book, ‘Captivate and Engage’, and talks about the shift from websites that display information . . . . . to websites that help people give, volunteer, register, or find services. A donor, a prospective volunteer, and clients seeking help arrive with different priorities and needs. Your website needs to make room for all of them!
This fast-paced conversation connects donor engagement to everyday operations: staff control over website updates, access to human support, and nonprofit website integrations that keep donation and event registration experiences connected. Kiersten favors a flexible technology stack, with tools selected for the jobs they do well.
Her buying rule deserves a place beside every software budget: “You should never add a tool that doesn’t make your life easier.” Volunteer management software, for example, needs to earn back the time required to set it up and maintain it.
Then comes AI search. Kiersten describes declining website traffic as people get answers directly from AI tools and recommends clear FAQs written around audience questions, plus accurate location and hours information.
And yes, the mailbox still gets a speaking part. Kiersten argues that direct mail remains effective, especially alongside email, social media, and a matching website landing page. Her campaign advice: “You want to take one story, one message, and then everything revolves around that one story.”
Watch the full episode with your next website update, tech purchase, or fundraising campaign in mind. Explore the book (and accompanying workbook) at captivateandengage.com, and learn more at firespring.com.
Key Takeaways
– Map each audience’s needs before planning website content and navigation.
– Give staff website control and connect donation and registration tools.
– Evaluate software against workload saved and ongoing management demands.
– Review AI descriptions of your organization; strengthen FAQs and factual details.
– Coordinate direct mail, email, social, and landing pages around one story.


Leave a Reply